Horton Grand Hotel

Posted: 01.24.2020 | Updated: 05.06.2025

Built in 1887 during San Diego’s post-railroad boom, the Grand Horton Hotel was a product of rapid growth and rising ambition. Designed by architects Comstock & Trotsche, it quickly became a symbol of the city’s expanding downtown and a hub for upscale travelers. However, the Horton Grand Hotel is haunted, with stories of ghostly apparitions and eerie occurrences that have fascinated guests and paranormal enthusiasts alike.

As time passed and redevelopment loomed, the city made the rare decision to dismantle the hotel brick by brick, preserving its legacy for future generations. The Grand Horton wasn’t just torn down—it was carefully saved and reborn as part of the modern Horton Grand Hotel that stands today.

Ready to uncover the haunted secrets of the Horton Grand Hotel? Join San Diego Ghosts for a walking tour through the city’s most haunted spots, where chilling tales and real ghost stories come to life.

Is The Horton Grand Hotel Haunted?

Located in the heart of San Diego’s historic Gaslamp Quarter, the Horton Grand Hotel captivates guests with its Victorian elegance, antique décor, and eerie legends. Originally two separate buildings—the Horton Grand and the Grand Horton—both were constructed in the 1880s, dismantled during redevelopment, and meticulously reconstructed brick by brick in the 1980s. This careful preservation of the past has carried not only the hotel’s charm into the present but perhaps its ghosts as well.

One of the most talked-about spirits said to haunt the hotel is Roger Whitaker, a gambler who allegedly met a tragic end in Room 309. According to legend, he was hiding from debt collectors when he was discovered and shot. Guests have reported flickering lights, cold drafts, strange voices, and even the unnerving sensation of someone sitting beside them on the bed. Others have spotted ghostly figures in 19th-century attire wandering the halls, adding to the hotel’s spectral reputation.

The Horton Grand has fully embraced its haunted lore, becoming a regular stop for local ghost tours and paranormal investigators. Whether visitors are drawn by the architecture or the afterlife, the hotel promises an unforgettable stay.

For those brave enough to spend the night, the Horton Grand Hotel offers a unique opportunity to experience San Diego’s haunted history firsthand. As one of the most famous haunted hotels in San Diego, whether it’s the flickering lights in Room 309 or the mysterious cold spots in the hallways, guests may find themselves wondering if the past truly never leaves.

History of the Horton Grand Hotel

The Horton Grand Hotel is named after Alonzo Horton, a key figure in the development of San Diego. In the late 1800s, Horton purchased land near the bay with the ambition of creating a new city that would thrive. His vision followed that of William Heath Davis, who had failed in his attempt to establish a colony in the area. While Davis faced significant resistance, Horton’s more widely accepted plans allowed his vision to flourish.

Horton’s development transformed Old Town into New Town, growing the city into the bustling metropolis it is today. His success is deeply tied to San Diego’s expansion, and in honor of his contributions, many locations and landmarks in the area bear his name, including the Horton Grand Hotel. The hotel’s origins, along with its significance in shaping the city, reflect the dynamic growth of San Diego in the 19th century.

In the 1970s, the city of San Diego purchased the Horton Grand Hotel and began a project to preserve its historic elements. The hotel was meticulously dismantled, brick by brick, with each piece numbered and reused in the reconstruction of the new building. This careful preservation not only retained the structure’s original charm but also combined the essence of another historic building, the Brooklyn-Kahle Saddlery Hotel, which was also set for demolition.

Preserving San Diego’s History

While the Horton Grand Hotel was being reconstructed, the preservation of San Diego’s historical heritage was of great importance. As part of the city’s efforts, the nearby Brooklyn-Kahle Saddlery Hotel was incorporated into the new building, merging the legacies of both hotels. This vision ensured that the charm and significance of these structures were preserved, contributing to the growth of the Gaslamp District, which remains a cultural hub.

The Gaslamp District itself holds a special place in history, primarily due to its unique lighting method. Instead of using gas lights, the district employed arc lighting—a groundbreaking form of electric light that powered the streets. This innovation made the Gaslamp one of the first districts to adopt such a method, adding another layer of historical significance to the area.

The combination of these historical elements has contributed to the enduring allure of the Horton Grand Hotel. By incorporating both past and modern designs, the hotel stands as a testament to San Diego’s rapid growth and dedication to preserving its roots. Today, visitors can experience the charm of the city’s past while enjoying the luxury of a carefully restored hotel.

The Haunting of the Horton Grand

Over two centuries ago, a gambler named Roger Whitaker checked into the Horton Grand Hotel, just like any other guest. He took his belongings to room 309 and went out to a bar for a few drinks. However, Whitaker had a reputation for being a cheater and a heavy drinker, traits that would soon lead to his downfall.

During a card game at a nearby dive bar, Whitaker was caught cheating. When he couldn’t pay his debt, his creditors threatened his life. After they fired a shot at him, hitting him, Whitaker fled back to the Horton Grand. He hid in his room, hoping to escape his pursuers by hiding in the wardrobe, but his past actions only made matters worse.

His creditors found him, and in his attempt to hide, they shot him to death while he cowered in the wardrobe. Room 309 has since become infamous for hauntings and eerie occurrences. Guests have reported their beds shaking violently while they slept, lights flickering on and off, and items moving in the bathroom without explanation.

Other Haunted Figures

Another well-known apparition at the Horton Grand Hotel is that of Ida Bailey, the former owner of a brothel that once occupied the land where the hotel stands today. Unlike Whitaker’s malevolent haunting, Ida’s spirit is often described as friendly. Guests have encountered her as a white, translucent mist or as a cold spot that passes through them as they walk the halls.

Guests and staff have also reported seeing apparitions dressed in 19th-century attire. These spirits seem to enjoy interacting with the living, often turning lights on and off or having conversations among themselves. They have been spotted floating down staircases, wandering through hallways, and even entering guests’ rooms without invitation.

In addition to these eerie encounters, some guests claim to have felt a sudden drop in temperature or an unexplained sense of being watched. Could it be that the spirits of the Horton Grand Hotel are still trying to tell their stories, or are they simply lingering in the afterlife, unwilling to leave?

Haunted San Diego

The Horton Grand Hotel isn’t just a beautifully preserved piece of San Diego’s past—it’s a living, breathing monument to the city’s rich and restless history. The hotel remains a place where the past refuses to stay buried. Whether it’s flickering lights, cold spots, or the creak of unseen footsteps, visitors continue to report unexplainable activity that keeps the legend of the Horton Grand alive.

Curious to experience it for yourself? Join San Diego Ghosts for a guided walking tour through the city’s most haunted locations, including the legendary Horton Grand Hotel, one of the most famous haunted hotels in San Diego. You’ll hear true stories, local lore, and spine-tingling accounts of ghostly encounters that make San Diego one of the West Coast’s most haunted cities. Book your tour today—if you dare.

Follow us on Facebook, Instagram, and TikTok—and don’t forget to keep reading our blog for even more spine-tingling stories from haunted San Diego.

Sources:

1. https://sandiegohistory.org/journal/1975/october/documents/
2. https://sandiegohistory.org/archives/biographysubject/aehorton/
3. https://sandiegohistory.org/journal/1967/october/began/
4. https://sandiegohistory.org/historic-clothing-collection/